Beautiful black woman in an orange sweatshirt, against a pink wall, natural curls out, her face is looking skeptical, hand on chin, very pensive, sincerelyireneb.com

Why Does Everything Now Need an AI Label?

At what point does using a tool to improve your work become a reason to overlook the person who created it?

I’m a lil’ pissed. OK fine, a lot pissed!

Recently, when Iโ€™m doodling on Pinterest, killing time or finding inspiration, and one of my blog post Pins pops up, my initial excitement and eagerness to heart it has been swiftly turning into disappointment. In the bottom-left corner of some of my Pins, Iโ€™m seeing โ€œAI Modifiedโ€. And Iโ€™m like, huh? What the hell is that? And to be clear, on my extremely limited budget, I do often use images from online stock library sites, or photos and graphics from Canva, but itโ€™s not always those being flagged with this new disrespectful label. It took me a minute to spot the ugly trend, but the images where I created the layout and then edited something within it using one of those Magic tools appear to be the shifty suspects.

Now, while this may seem like a relatively small issue, itโ€™s really not when you start considering the bigger picture.

Beautiful black woman, leaned back in a chair wearing an edgy tan suit, blazer open with a black leather top. Pointing to papers on a wall that read 'where is the end' and not gonna miss you, sincerelyireneb.com

AI Modified? Seriously? 

I love Canva. I have the Pro version, and itโ€™s easy to use, navigate and create with, even for someone with not one artistic bone in my body. Style, flair, an eye for design, yes, but actually drawing, painting, and things of that nature, absolutely not. That gene didnโ€™t skip me; it wouldnโ€™t even look me in the eye.

So when I’m sourcing images, curating them, playing around with layouts, positioning, colours, composition, and all the little details that go into making something look the way I envision it, I did that, me. And I try to rein myself in, timebox myself even, so I donโ€™t spend a ridiculous amount of time getting one image just right. Because apparently, that’s how I like to spend my time in my Canva-cave.

Then, perhaps I’ll use one of Canva’s Magic tools to sharpen a particular element or make a small adjustment to my work. Nothing particularly groundbreaking. Itโ€™s still all me, my design choices, with just a little polish, and now here comes this rude label. My finished image suddenly carries an AI-modified or AI-content designation.

I didnโ€™t speak into a prompt and have AI create an image based on words I gave it, but youโ€™re telling me using the Magic Eraser on a spot here and there means that now AI gets to share in my already limited art talents. I think the fuck not!

Me no likey. Me no likey one lil’ bit. Who came up with this?

Iโ€™m not all the way an AI-hater. I appreciate it for its efficiency in aiding my work, enhancing my thoughts or ideas. For something routine or mundane that I don’t need to spend gobs of time reinventing the wheel on, AI churns it out nicely. Do I hate the number of data centres being spun up across the world to support the growing demand for AI? One hundred percent. And yet now, I have a whole new issue with the lack of distinction between something created by AI and something created by a person, me, who happened to use an AI-assisted feature. โ€œAI Modifiedโ€ is giving the person who showed up at the end of the group project having only added their name to other peopleโ€™s work, yet is on stage cheesing with the real-deal workers. We all hate that person.

AI, is this who you want to be as well?

We’re in danger of losing sight of the distinction when we start treating every piece of work touched in any way by an AI tool as though AI created the entire thing. Because thatโ€™s how I see it, and it canโ€™t just be me.

A 'No Trespassing' sign posted on a tree, the bark, sincerelyireneb.com

It’s Not Just an Image Thing 

And this isn’t just about images.

Think about written content. An amazing, random thought comes to you from nowhere. You spend hours developing that thought into an idea, a plan. You start adding to it, drawing from personal experiences, researching a subject, and putting it all into words. Sure, you might use an AI tool to check grammar, spelling, suggest an alternative sentence, or help tidy up a paragraph.

Does that suddenly mean the entire piece is AI-generated? Hell-to-the-no!

What about the original thinking? Our human experiences? The odd and quirky perspective? And what about your unique personality behind the words? Because as humans, we are all unique.

At what point does a lilโ€™ assistance become authorship?

Yes, transparency is needed, Iโ€™m all for that. But while transparency about the use of these tools matters, so does accurately representing the human contribution.

Woman wearing glassed seated at a desk, office setting, chin resting on her hand, appearing defeated, as she looks at the back of a robot, indicating AI, who is working at the desk in front of her, indicating the AI it taking over, sincerelyireneb.com

Say It With Me: Tools Don’t Get the Credit 

Think about it like this.

Photography has been around since the 1800s (and yes, while I Googled that, I only did it to confirm I was right). Now, thinking about photographers today, they spend hours finding the right location, waiting for the perfect light, composing their shots, adjusting camera settings, and capturing something that reflects their creative vision. I remember my youngestโ€™s high-school prom and a friendโ€™s hubby, whose hobby is photography, doing just this.

They might then take that photograph into editing software to adjust the contrast, sharpen certain details, enhance the colours, remove a distracting element, and whatnot. A more elevated version of my Canva Magic Eraser tool.

So, does that mean Canon or Nikon gets to claim creative credit for the photograph? Canon-Created? Nikon-Nudged?

What about Adobe? Does using Photoshop mean Adobe deserves recognition, too? Adobe-Advised. Of course not. Where does it end?

The equipment and software are simply tools that help facilitate the creative process. The photographer is still bringing their vision to life.

Iโ€™ll do you one more. Iโ€™m a music lover too. Genre be damned, as long as itโ€™s good, itโ€™s good. So what about everyoneโ€™s favourite, NOT, Auto-Tune.

Now, I’m going to use two women who need absolutely no introduction: Whitney Houston (RIP) and Mariah Carey. Both are extraordinary vocalists. Their talent, vocal range, control, and artistry aren’t things that can simply be manufactured by technology. Not that they even need it. Me, on the other hand, Iโ€™m gonna need about 50 gabillion takes.

Could they have walked into a recording studio and chosen to use Auto-Tune or other audio-enhancement tools to polish a recording? Absolutely. But while the recordings might involve some level of technology, who in their right mind would fix their lips to credit Auto-Tune? A tool didn’t create their voices or give them the ability to harmonize and do those vocal runs the way only they can do.

Thatโ€™s the distinction I’m trying to make with AI and AI modified. There’s a clear difference between using a tool to enhance something you’ve created and relying on that tool entirely to create something you couldn’t otherwise produce yourself.

Hands circling gambling table chips, as in winnings, cards next to chips, indicating 'mine' no one should try to touch, sincerelyireneb.com

Don’t Erase the Real Work 

There’s a bigger life lesson in this, too.

When I see AI Modified slapped on my work, it feels like it stripped away all the effort I put in to get to my finished product. Kind of like in life, when we have a habit of overlooking the work (the good, bad, and shit) that went into something because we’re often more focused on the end result rather than what it took to get us there.

People see the promotion, not the years of experience and effort behind it. They see the finished product or business, but not the late nights, setbacks, and decisions that went into building it. We see people living a dream life, or just being happy, yet have no idea what they went through, or what it took to get them there.

There’s nothing wrong with getting a little help along the way, but receiving help doesn’t erase the work you’ve put in yourself.

AI Modified feels like a cheat, like itโ€™s cheating me or stealing from me. Stealing my hard work, my time, my creativity. It gets to skip over all the decisions, the changes, the resets, and just stand on stage for the finale and take the applause.

Iโ€™m going to use those โ€˜toolsโ€™ a little less now. Be more cautious. Figure out a way to slide them in just enough that they donโ€™t overshadow me. And see if that works.

I still created it. The glory, the win, or the utter failure is mine. And I’d quite like that to count and be clear.

Where do you draw the line between AI assistance and AI creation? And are these labels doing more damage to human creativity than we realise? I’d love to hear your thoughts. 

Found this helpful? Spread the word. Tag me on Instagram @sincerely_ireneb

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *